Experience vs. Appearance: Designing for Authentic Communication

Close your eyes and remember the most powerful architectural experience you've ever had. Was it what you saw, or what you felt? The cold touch of stone, the shifting patterns of light, the sudden change in acoustics as you entered a new space?

The disconnect: While we experience architecture with all our senses, we often design it primarily for appearance.

The Experience-Appearance Gap

Architecture conveys effects that should create a certain thought or emotion in us. Yet much contemporary architecture prioritizes visual impact over multisensory experience.

• Buildings designed to look good in renderings rather than feel good in reality

• Spaces optimized for photographs rather than human comfort

• Materials selected for appearance rather than tactile quality

• Forms that impress from a distance but fail at human scale

This creates architecture that photographs well but fails to create authentic connections with its users.

The Experience Audit for Designers

Before finalizing any design, apply these experiential lenses:

1. Sensory Inventory
❓ Ask: How does your design engage each of the five senses?
✅ Action: Document intended sensory effects for sight, sound, touch, smell, and even taste.

2. Temporal Mapping
❓ Ask: How does your building change over time—days, seasons, years?
✅ Action: Create a simple matrix showing experience variations in different conditions.

3. Memory Potential
❓ Ask: Which elements will create lasting memories for users?
✅ Action: Identify 3-5 memory points in your design.

Try this today: Visit a space you know well and document which sensory aspects create the strongest impression on you.

Designing for Erlebnis

The Blur Building exemplifies erlebnis—Gadamer's concept of lived experience. Visitors don’t just view the building, they participate in its creation.

• The mist responds to environmental conditions, creating a different experience each time.

• Movement through the cloud is undirected, making each journey unique.

• The disorientation activates visitors' imaginations, compelling them to create personal narratives.

My philosophy is that what matters most is how we experienced and lived through something.

Why Authentic Experience Matters

Designing for authentic experience rather than appearance creates architecture with:

1. Lasting Impact
   Sensory memories endure longer than visual impressions.
   Strategy: Design "memory anchors" that engage multiple senses.

2. Deeper Connection
   Users form emotional bonds with spaces that offer rich experiences.
   Strategy: Create opportunities for personal narrative within your spaces.

3. True Differentiation
   While appearances can be copied, experiences are unique.
   Strategy: Identify the experiential qualities that make your project singular.

The Authentic Experience Toolbox

When developing experience-focused design consider this:

• Material transitions that invite touch

• Acoustic variations that signal threshold moments

• Light choreography that marks the passage of time

• Olfactory elements that create memory associations

We think, imagine and direct our perception exactly where we imagine it to be necessary. Good architecture provides the conditions for this imagination.

From Theory to Practice

Need help shifting your practice from appearance-focused to experience-centered design? My experience mapping consultations help architects identify and enhance the multisensory aspects of their projects.

Join the leaders who have transformed their approach to architecture:

• Students & Early Practitioners [Review & Coaching] 
  Receive tailored guidance on your portfolio.
  (40+ reviews delivered)

  
  

• Architects & Firms [Design Impact Assessment]:
  Identify future heritage potential in your project.
  (200+ design audits completed)

  
  

• Leaders & Institutions [Heritage Strategy Consultation]:
  Develop a strategy for your vision.
  (10+ premium strategies implemented)

→ Book a Discovery Call via e-mail: [email protected]